Book Review: Raising Your Spirited Child

Raising Your Spirited Child* by Mary Sheedy Kurcinka

The subtitle for this gem of a book is “A guide for parents whose child is more: intense, sensitive, perceptive, persistent, energetic.” If you have a child that fits this description, you must get your hands on a copy of this book. I have a little one who is quite spirited, and whenever I find myself at my wit’s end, it is this book that reminds me of the beauty of having a spirited child and helps me get back on track.

The last time I ran to this book was when my spirited one was newly three. We were standing at the back of the church during mass. I was holding her new baby brother in the baby carrier, and she was sitting at my feet. I was feeling thankful that, for the moment, everyone was quiet and well behaved. I peaked around the baby to look down at my cherub and discovered that she was wearing nothing but her undies. I was shocked and horrified. “Put your clothes on!” I hissed. “No.” Mortified, I picked her up and carried her to the basement where I begged, threatened, cajoled and otherwise failed to get her into her clothes. A very kind woman offered to help. Completely at a loss, I gratefully accepted her help. She dug in her purse looking for something with which to bribe a sullen 3 year old. She found an unopened tube of chapstick and offered it to my little one if she would just put on her clothes. My precious daughter’s response was simply to cross her arms and glare at the kind woman who then replied, “Most kids aren’t this stubborn!”

What I love about this book is the positive tone and the practical. There’s a section devoted to finding new labels to describe the spirited behaviors that can be so taxing to parents. Kurcinka encourages you to call up your favorite image of your spirited child, the one that “includes the snappy eyes, the infectious grin, the agile body, or the astounding question,” and to hold that image while you “discover the hidden potential” in a list of obnoxious characteristics. Unpredictable becomes flexible and creative. My stubborn, naked child becomes assertive and persistent in the face of challenges. Reading this section actually takes me from the despair (how I am ever going to survive parenting this child?!?!) to a feeling of being abundantly blessed with a fascinating child who will one day do, and in fact already does, amazing things.

Once she’s helped you obtain this attitude change, Kurcinka provides an in depth course on temperament. Here she discusses introversion versus extroversion and each of the “more” characteristics (intensity, sensitivity, persistence, distractibility, adaptability, regularity, energy, first reaction and mood). In each section she provides a sensitive and supportive overview of the personality trait as well as sound practical advice for preventing and managing the difficulties it can cause. Upon re-reading this book, I was reminded of my daughter’s sensitivity to things like the temperature of a room and the feeling of her clothes on her skin. Combine this sensitivity with her intensity and persistence, and well, you end up with a naked kid who refuses to get dressed in the back of the church.

Thanks to the sensitive and practical advice in this book, we now think carefully about what my daughter wears to church. A few minutes spent considering the comfort of her clothes, choosing some layers, and discussing whether that really pretty dress will still feel comfortable when she’s been sitting on a wooden pew for a while goes a long way toward a more peaceful Sunday morning.

As a spirited adult, I especially appreciate the sections addressing how to cope “if you’re intense/sensitive/persistent too.” Again, Kurcinka’s tone is always encouraging and never condemning. These traits aren’t good or bad. Being “intense” or “sensitive” is no more of moral issue than being right- or left-handed. It simply helps to know what you are so that you can behave appropriately.

The last third of Raising Your Spirited Child is full of practical advice for specific situations. There’s a chapter on tantrums, as well as bedtime, mealtime, and getting dressed. The final chapters address the social life of a spirited child including helping the spirited child succeed in school.

Raising a spirited child is a unique challenge. It can be overwhelming, particularly when your parenting philosophy is opposed to punitive and physical discipline. So many parenting books, particularly those with a “Christian” bent, recommend breaking a child’s spirit. But that spirit is a gift from God. Some of the Church’s most celebrated saints were spirited. Joan of Arc didn’t let others tell her what to wear. St. Peter was a notorious hot head. No, we’re not to break our child’s spirit, we’re to instruct and guide it so that he can learn to use it for God’s greater glory.

*Because I live in a state where it’s prohibited by law, I receive no compensation if you buy stuff through my Amazon link. So feel free to click through someone else’s link to spend your money.



  1. Clicked through via the comments on Conversion Diary….I have this book, too, and I just love how it helps parents remember to reframe their struggles. This book upholds the dignity of the child, which can be a difficult thing to do in the face of spiritedness. I liked reading your review and agree with your assessment of Christian books on this topic. Thanks!

  2. Thanks, Anne! Watch this space – I plan to review some more books in the same vein. I also loved “Living With Intensity.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: